"Green Mars" - читать интересную книгу автора (Robinson Kim Stanley)

PART 8 Social Engineering

Where were you born?

Denver.

Where did you grow up?

Rock. Boulder.

What were you like as a child?

I don#8217;t know.

Give me your impressions.

I wanted to know why.

You were curious?

Very curious.

Did you play with science kits?

All of them.

And your friends?

I don#8217;t remember.

Try for anything.

I don#8217;t think I had many friends.

Were you ambidextrous as a child?

I don#8217;t remember.

Think about your science experiments. Did you use both hands when you did them?

I believe it was often necessary.

You wrote with your right hand?

I do now. I did then as well. Yes. As a child.

And did you do anything with your left hand? Brush your teeth, comb your hair, eat, point at things, throw balls?

I did all those things with my right hand. Would it matter ifl hadn#8217;t?

Well, you see, in cases of aphasia, the strong right-handers all conform pretty well to a certain profile. Activities are located, or it is better to say coordinated, at certain places in the brain. When we determine precisely the problems the aphasic is experiencing, we can tell pretty well where the lesions in the brain are located. And vice versa. But with left-handers and ambidextrous people there is no such pattern. One might say that every left-handed and ambidextrous brain is organized differently.

You know most of Hiroko#8217;s ectogene children are left-handed.

Yes, I know. I#8217;ve spoken with her about it, but she claims she doesn#8217;t know why. She says it may be a result of being born on Mars.

Do you find this plausible?

Well, handedness is still poorly understood in any case, and the effects of the lighter gravity #8230; we#8217;ll be sorting those out for centuries, won#8217;t we.

I suppose so.

You don#8217;t like the idea of that, do you?

I would rather get answers.

What if all your questions were answered? Would you be happy then?

I find it hard to imagine such a #8212; state. A fairly small percentage of my questions have answers.

But that#8217;s rather wonderful, don#8217;t you agree?

No. It wouldn#8217;t be scientific to agree.

You conceive of science as nothing more than answers to questions?

As a system for generating answers.

And what is the purpose of that?

#8230; To know.

And what will you do with your knowledge?

#8230; Find out more.

But why?

I don#8217;t know. It#8217;s the way I am.

Shouldn#8217;t some of your questions be directed that way #8212; to finding out why you are the way you are?

I don#8217;t think you can get good answers to questions about #8212; human nature. Better to think of it as a black box. You can#8217;t apply the scientific method. Not well enough to be sure of your answers.

In psychology we believe we have scientifically identified a certain pathology in which a person needs to know everything because he is afraid of not knowing. It#8217;s a pathology of monocausotaxophilia, as Poppel called it, the love of single causes that explain everything. This can become fear of a lack of causes. Because the lack might be dangerous. The knowledge-seeking becomes primarily defensive, in that it is a way of denying fear when one really is afraid. At its worst it isn#8217;t even knowledge-seeking, because when the answers arrive they cease to be of interest, as they are no longer dangerous. So that reality itself doesn#8217;t matter to such a person.

Everyone tries to avoid danger. But motivations are always multiple. And different from action to action. Time to time. Any patterns are a matter of #8212; observer#8217;s speculation.

Psychology is a science in which the observer becomes intimately involved with the subject of observation.

That#8217;s one of the reasons I don#8217;t think it#8217;s a science.

It is certainly a science. One of its tenets is, if you want to know more, care more. Every astronomer loves the stars. Otherwise why study them so?

Because they are mysteries.

What do you care about?

I care about truth.

The truth is not a very good lover.

It isn#8217;t love I#8217;m looking for.

Are you sure?

No surer than anyone else who thinks about #8212; motivations.

You agree we have motivations?

Yes. But science cannot explain them.

So they are part of your great unexplainable.

Yes.

And so you focus your attention on other things.

Yes.

But the motivations are still there.

Oh yes.

What did you read when you were young?

All kinds of things.

What were some of your favorite books?

Sherlock Holmes. Other detective stories. The Thinking Machine. Dr. Thorndyke.

Did your parents punish you if you got upset?

I don#8217;t think so. They didn#8217;t like me making a fuss. But I think they were just ordinary in that respect.

Did you ever see them get upset?

I don#8217;t remember.

Did you ever see them shout, or cry?

I never heard them shout. Sometimes.my mom cried, I think.

Did you know why?

No.

Did you wonder why?

I don#8217;t remember. WouU it matter if I had?

What do you mean?

I mean, if I had had one kind of past. I could still have turned into any kind of person. Depending on my reaction to the #8212; events. And if I had had another kind of past. The same variations would have followed. So that your line of questioning is useless. In that it has no explanatory rigor. It#8217;s an imitation of the scientific method.

I consider your conception of science to be as parsimonious and reductive as your scientific activities. Essentially you are saying we should not study the human mind in a scientific manner because it is too complex to make the study easy. That#8217;s not very bold of you. The universe outside us is complex too, but you don#8217;t advise avoiding that. Why so with the universe inside?

You can#8217;t isolate factors, you can#8217;t repeat conditions, you can#8217;t set up experiments with controls, you can#8217;t makefalsifiable hypotheses. The whole apparatus of science is unavailable to you.

Think about the first scientists for a while.

The Greeks?

Before that. Prehistory was not just a formless timeless round of the seasons, you know. We tend to think of those people as if they resembled our own unconscious minds, but they were not like that. For a hundred thousand years at least we have been as intellectual as we are now. Probably more like half a million years. And every age has its great scientists, and they all had to work in the context of their times, like we_ do. For the early ones, there were hardly explanations for anything #8212; nature was as whole and complex and mysterious as our own minds are to us now, but what could they do? They had to begin somewhere, eh? This is what you must remember. And it took thousands of years to learn the plants, the animals, the use of fire, rocks, axes, bows and arrows, shelter, clothing. Then pottery, crops, metallurgy. All so slow!}#8217;, with such effort. And all passed along by word of mouth, from one scientist to the next. And all the while there were no doubt people saying, it#8217;s too complex to be sure of anything. Why should we try at all? Galileo said, #8220;The ancients had good reason to think the first scientists among the gods, seeing that common minds have so little curiosity. The small . hints that began the great inventions were part of not a trivial but a superhuman spirit.#8221; Superhuman! Or merely the best parts of ourselves, the bold minds of each generation. The scientists. And over the millennia we have pieced together a model of the world, a paradigm that is quite precise and powerful, yes?

But haven#8217;t we tried just as hard all these years #8212; with little success #8212; to understand ourselves?

Say we have. Maybe it takes longer. But look, we have made quite a bit of progress there too. And not just recently. By observation alone the Greeks discovered the four temperaments, and only recently have we learned enough about the brain to say what the neurological basis of this phenomenon is.

You believe in the four temperaments?

Oh yes. They are confirmable by experiment, if you will. As are so many, many things about the human mind. Perhaps it is not physics, perhaps it will never be physics. It could be that we are simply more complex and unpredictable than the universe.

That hardly seems likely. We are made of atoms after all.

But animated! Driven by the green force, alive with spirit, the great unexplainable!

Chemical reactions #8230;

But why life? It#8217;s more than reactions. There is a drive toward com-plexification that is directly opposed to the physical law of entropy. Why should that be?

I don#8217;t know.

Why do you dislike it so when you can#8217;t say why?

I don#8217;t know.

This mystery of life is a holy thing. It is our freedom. We have shot out of physical reality, we exist now in a kind of godlike freedom, and the mystery is integral to it.

No. We are still physical reality. Atoms in their rounds. Determined on most scales, random on some others.

Ah well. We disagree. But either way, the scientist#8217;s job is to explore everything. No matter the difficulties! To stay open, to accept ambiguity. To attempt to fuse with the object of knowledge. To admit that there are values shot through the whole enterprise. To love it. To work toward discovering the values by which we should live. To work to enact those values in the world. To explore #8212; and more than that #8212; to create!

I#8217;ll have to think about that.

Observation is never enough. Besides it wasn#8217;t their experiment anyway. Desmond came to Dorsa Brevia, and Sax went to find him. #8220;Is Peter still flying?#8221;

#8220;Why yes. He spends a fair amount of time in space, if that#8217;s what you mean.#8221;

#8220;Yes. Can you get me in#8217;touch with him?#8221;

#8220;Sure I can.#8221; Quizzical expression on Desmond#8217;s cracked face. #8220;Your speech is getting better and better, Sax. What have they been doing to you?#8221;

#8220;Gerontological treatments. Also growth hormone, L-dopa, serotonin, other chemicals. Stuff out of starfish.#8221;

#8220;Grew you a new brain, did they?#8221;

#8220;Yes. Parts anyway. Synergic synaptic stimulus. Also a lot of talking with Michel.#8221;

#8220;Uh-oh!#8221;

#8220;It#8217;s still me.#8221;

Desmond#8217;s laugh was an animal noise. #8220;I can see that. Listen, I#8217;ll be off again in a couple days, and I#8217;ll take you to Peter#8217;s airport.#8221;

#8220;Thanks.#8221;

Grew a new brain. Not an accurate way of putting it. The lesion had been sustained in the posterior third of the inferior frontal convolution. Tissues dead as a result of interruption of focused ultrasound memory-speech stimulation during interrogation. A stroke. Broca#8217;s aphasia. Difficulty with motor apparatus of speech, little melody, difficulty in initiating utterances, reduction to tele-gramese, mostly nouns and simplest forms of verbs. A battery of tests determined that most other cognitive functions were unimpaired. He wasn#8217;t so sure; he had understood people speaking to him, his thinking had been much the same as far as he could tell, and he had had no trouble with the spatial and other nonlinguistic tests. But when he tried to talk, sudden betrayal #8212; in the mouth and in the mind. Things lost their names.

Strangely enough, without names they were still things. He could see them and think about them in terms of shapes, or numbers. Formula of description. Various combinations of conic sections and the six surfaces of revolution symmetrical around an axis, the plane, the sphere, the cylinder, the catenoid, the unduloid, and the nodoid; shapes without the names, but the shapes alone were like names. Spatializing language.

But it turned out that remembering without words was hard. A method had to be borrowed, the palace-of-memory method, spatial to begin with. A space in the mind was established to resemble the inside of the Echus Overlook labs, which he recalled well enough to walk around in in his mind, names or no. And in each place an object. Or another place. On one counter, all the Acheron labs. On top of the refrigerator, Boulder, Colorado. And so he remembered all the shapes he thought by their location in the mental lab.

And then sometimes the name would come. But when he knew the name and tried to say it, it was very possible that the wrong one would come out of his mouth. He had always had a tendency this way. After sessions of his best thinking, when everything had been quite clear to him, it had sometimes been difficult to translate his thoughts onto the plane of language, which did not match well the kind of thinking he had been doing. So that talking had been work. But nothing like this, this halting, erratic, treacherous groping, which usually either failed or betrayed. Frustrating in the extreme. Painful. Although preferable to Wernicke#8217;s aphasia, certainly, in which one babbled volubly, unaware that one was making no sense at all. Just as he had had a premorbid tendency to lose the words for things, there were people who tended towards Wernicke#8217;s without the excuse of brain damage. As Art had noted. Sax preferred his own problem.

Ursula and Vlad had come to him. #8220;Aphasia is different for every person,#8221; Ursula said. #8220;There are patterns, and clusters of symptoms that usually go with certain lesion patterns in right-handed adults. But in extraordinary minds there are a lot of exceptions. Already we see that your cognitive functions have remained very high for someone with your degree of language difficulties. Probably a lot of your thought in math and physics did not take place using language.#8221;

#8220;That#8217;s right.#8221;

#8220;And if it was geometrical thinking rather than analytical, it probably took place in the right hemisphere of the brain rather than the left. And your right hemisphere was spared.#8221;

Sax nodded, not trusting himself to speak.

#8220;So, prospects for recovery vary widely. There is almost always improvement. Children in particular are very adaptable. When they have head injuries even a circumscribed lesion may cause serious problems, but there is almost always recovery. A whole hemisphere of the brain can be removed from a child if a problem makes it necessary, and all the functions be releamed by the remaining half. This is because of the incredible growth in the child#8217;s brain. For adults it is different. Specialization has occurred, so that circumscribed lesions cause a specific limited damage. But once a skill has been destroyed in a mature brain, you don#8217;t often see significant improvement.#8221;

#8220;The treat. The treatment.#8221;

#8220;Exactly. But you see, the brain is precisely one of the places where the gerontological treatment has the most trouble penetrating. We#8217;ve been working on that, however. We#8217;ve designed a stimulus package to be used in concert with the treatment, when faced with cases of brain damage. It may become a regular part of the treatment, if the trials continue to have good results. We haven#8217;t done this in too many human trials yet, you see. The injection increases brain plasticity by stimulating axon and dendritic spine growth, and the sensitivity of Hebb synapses. The corpus callosurn is particularly affected, and the hemisphere opposite to the lesioned side. Learning can build whole new neural networks there.#8221; #8220;Do it,#8221; Sax said.

Destruction is creation. Become as a little child. Language as space, a kind of mathematical notation, geometric locations in the lab of memory. Reading. Maps. Codes, substitutions, the secret names of things. The glorious inrush of a word. The joy of chatter. Every color#8217;s wavelength, by number. That sand is orange, tan, blond, yellow, sienna, umber, burnt umber, ochre. That sky is cerulean, cobalt, lavender, mauve, violet, Prussian, indigo, egglant, midnight. Just to look at color charts with words, the rich intensity of colors, the sounds of the words #8212; he wanted more. A name for every wavelength of the visible spectrum, why not? Why be so stingy? The .59-micron wavelength is so much more blue than .6, and .61 is so much more red#8230; They needed more words for purples, the way Eskimos needed more words for snow. People always used that example, and Eskimos did have about twenty words for snow; but scientists had over three hundred words for snow, and who ever gave scientists credit for paying attention to their world? No two snowflakes alike. Thisness. Buh, buh. Bean, bear, bun, burr, bent, bomb. Buh. That place where my arm bends is my elbow! Mars looks like a pumpkin! The air is cold. And poisoned by carbon dioxide.

There were parts of his inner speech which were composed entirely of old cliches, coming no doubt from what Michel called #8220;overlearned#8221; activities in his past, which had so permeated his mind that they had survived the damage. Clean design, good data, parts per billion, bad results. Then cutting through these comfortable formulations, as if from a separate language entirely, were the new perceptions, and the new phrases groping to express them. Synaptic synergies. Actual speech from either realm was still welcome. The exhilaration of normality. How he had taken it for granted. Michel came by to talk every day, helping him to build this new brain. Michel harbored some very alarming beliefs for a man of science. The four elements, the four temperaments, alchemical formulations of all kinds, philosophical positions parading as science#8230; #8220;Didn#8217;t you once ask me if I could change lead to gold?#8221;

#8220;I don#8217;t think so.#8221;

#8220;Why do you spend so much time talking to me, Michel?#8221; #8220;I like talking to you, Sax. You say something new every day.#8221; #8220;I like this throwing things with my left hand.#8221; #8220;I can see that. It#8217;s possible you may end up a left-hander. Or ambidextrous, because your left brain is so powerful, I can#8217;t imagine it will lag much, no matter the lesion.#8221;

#8220;Mars looks like an iron-cored ball of old planetesimals.#8221;

Desmond flew him to the Red sanctuary in Wallace Crater, where Peter often stayed. And Peter was there, Peter son of Mars, tall fast and strong, graceful, friendly although impersonal, distant, absorbed in his own work and his own life. Simonlike. Sax told him what he wanted to do, and why. He still stumbled in his speech occasionally. But it was so much better than it had been before that he hardly minded when he did. Forge on! Like talking in a foreign language. All languages were foreign languages to him now. Except his idiolect of shapes. But it was no aggravation #8212; on the contrary, such a relief to do even so well. To have the fog clearing away from the names, have the mind-mouth connections restored. Even if in a new and chancy way. A chance to learn. Sometimes he liked the new way. One#8217;s reality might indeed depend on one#8217;s scientific paradigm, but it mostly definitely depended on one#8217;s brain structure. Change that and your paradigms might as well follow. You can#8217;t fight progress. Nor progressive differentiation. #8220;Do you understand?#8221;

#8220;Oh, I understand,#8221; Peter said, grinning widely. #8220;I think it#8217;s a very good idea. Very important. It will take me a few days to get the plane ready.#8221;

- - Ann arrived at the shelter, looking tired and old. She greeted Sax curtly, her old antipathy as strong as ever. Sax did not know what to say to her. Was this a new problem?

He decided to wait until Peter had talked to her, and see if that made any difference. He waited. Nowadays if he didn#8217;t talk no one bothered him. Advantages everywhere.

She came back from a talk with Peter, to eat a meal with the other Reds in their little commons, and yes she stared at him curiously. Looking over the heads of the others at him as if inspecting a new cliff on the Martian landscape. Intent and objective. Evaluative. A status change in a dynamic system is a data point that speaks to a theory. Supporting or troubling. What are you? Why are you doing this?

He met her stare calmly, tried to field it, to turn it around. Yes I am still Sax. I have changed. Who are you? Why haven#8217;t you changed? Why do you still look at me like that? I have experienced an injury. The premorbid individual is not there anymore, not quite. I have been given an experimental treatment, I feel fine, I am not the man you knew. And why haven#8217;t you changed?

If enough data points trouble the theory, the theory may be wrong. If the theory is basic, the paradigm may have to change.

She sat down to eat. It was doubtful she had read his mind in, that much detail. But a great pleasure nevertheless, to be able to meet her eye!

He got in the little cockpit with Peter and just after the timeslip they bounced down the bedrock runway, accelerating hard and tilting up at the black sky, the big streamlined space plane vibrating under them. Sax lay back, crushed into his seat, and waited for the plane to curve over that asymptotic hill at the top of its course, slowing as it rose less steeply, until it was in a gentle rise through the high stratosphere, making the transition from plane to rocket as the atmosphere thinned to its last attenuated level, a hundred kilometers high, where the gases of the Russell cocktail were annihilated daily by incoming UV rays. The plane#8217;s skin was glowing with heat. Through the filtered glass of the cockpit it was the color of the sun at sunset. No doubt it was affecting their night vision. Below the planet was all dark, except for very faint patches of starlit glaciers in Hellas Basin. They were rising still. A widening gyre. Stars packed the blackness of what looked like an enormous black hemisphere, standing on an enormous black plane. Night sky, night Mars. They rose and rose again. The incandescent rocket was translucent yellow, hallucinatorily bright and sleek. The latest thing from Vishniac, designed in part by Spencer, and made of an inter-metallic compound, chiefly gamma titanium aluminum, rendered superplastic for the manufacture of heat-resistant engine parts as well as the exterior skin, which dimmed a bit as they rose higher and it cooled. He could imagine the beautiful latticework of the gamma titanium aluminum, patterned in a tapestry of nodoids and catenoids like hooks and eyes, vibrating madly with the heat. They were building such things these days. Ground-to-space planes. Walk out into your backyard and fly to Mars in an aluminum can.

Sax described what he wanted to do next after this. Peter laughed.

#8220;Do you think Vishniac can do it?#8221;

#8220;Oh yeah.#8221;

#8220;There are some design problems.#8221;

#8220;I know, I know. But they#8217;ll solve them. I mean you don#8217;t have to be a rocket scientist to be a rocket scientist.#8221;

#8220;That#8217;s very true.#8221;

Peter sang to pass the hours. Sax joined in when he knew the words #8212; as in #8220;Sixteen Tons,#8221; a satisfying song. Peter told the story of how he had escaped from the falling elevator. What it had been like to float in an,EVA suit, alone for two days. #8220;Somehow it gave me a taste for it, that#8217;s all. I know that sounds strange.#8221;

#8220;I understand.#8221; The shapes out here were so big and pure. The color of things.

#8220;What was it like to learn to talk again?#8221;

#8220;I have to concentrate to do it. I have to think hard. Things surprise me all the time. Things I used to know and forgot. Things I never knew. Things I learned just before the injury. That period is usually occluded forever. But it was so important. When I was working around the glacier. I have to talk to your mom about that. It isn#8217;t like she thinks. You know, the land. The new plants out there. The yellow butterfly sun. It doesn#8217;t have to be #8230;#8221;

#8220;You should talk to her.#8221;

#8220;She doesn#8217;t like me.#8221;

#8220;Talk to her when we get back.#8221;

The altimeter indicated 250 kilometers above the surface. The plane plowed up toward Cassiopeia. Every star had a distinct color, different from any other. Or there were at least fifty of them. Below them, on the eastern edge of the black disk, the terminator appeared, zebra-banded sandy ochre and shadowy black. The thin crescent of sunlit Mars gave him the sudden clear perception of the disk as a great spheroid. A ball spinning through the galaxy of stars. The great huge continent-mountain of Elysium bulked over the horizon, its shape perfectly delineated by the horizontal#8217; shadows. They were looking down the length of its long saddleback, Hecates Tholus almost hidden behind the cone of Elysium Mons, Albor Tholus off to the side.

#8220;There it is,#8221; Peter said, and pointed up through the clear cockpit. Above them, to the east, the eastern edge of the aerial lens was silver in the morning light, the rest of it still in the planet#8217;s shadow.

#8220;Are we close enough yet?#8221; Sax asked.

#8220;Almost.#8221;

Sax looked down again at the thickening crescent of the morning. There on the dark rough highlands of Hesperia, a cloud of smoke was billowing up from the dark surface just beyond the terminator, into the morning light. Even at their height they were in that cloud still, in the part that was no longer visible. The lens itself was surfing on that invisible thermal, using its lift and the pressure of sunlight to hold its position over the burn zone.

Now the entire lens was in the sunlight, looking like an enormous silver parachute with nothing underneath it. Its silver was also violet, sky-colored. The cup was a section of a sphere, a thousand kilometers across, its center some fifty kilometers above its rim. Spinning like a Frisbee. There was a hole at the peak, where the sunlight poured straight through. Everywhere else the circular mirror strips that made up the cup were reflecting the light from the sun and the soletta, inward and down onto a moving point on the surface below, bringing to bear so much light that it was igniting basalt. The lens mirrors heated up to almost 900°K, and the liquefied rock down there was reaching 5,000°K. Degassing vola-tiles.

Into Sax#8217;s mind, as he considered the great object flying over them, came the image of a magnifying glass, held over dry weeds and an aspen branch. Smoke, flame, fire. The concentrated rays of the sun. Photon assault. #8220;Aren#8217;t we close enough yet? It looks like it#8217;s right over us.#8221;

#8220;No, we#8217;re well out from under the edge. It wouldn#8217;t do to get under that thing, although I suppose the focus wouldn#8217;t be right to fry us. Anyway it#8217;s moving over the burn zone at almost a thousand kilometers an hour.#8221;

#8220;Like jets when I was young.#8221;

#8220;Uh.#8221; Green lights blinked on one of his consoles. #8220;Okay, here we go.#8221;

He pulled back on the stick and the plane stood on its tail, rising straight at the lens, which was still another hundred kilometers higher than they were, and well to the west of them. Peter pushed a button on the console. The whole plane jerked as a bank of fletched missiles appeared from under the plane#8217;s stubby wings, lofting with them and then igniting like magnesium flares and shooting up and away, toward the lens. Pinpricks of yellow fire against that huge silvery UFO, eventually disappearing from sight. Sax waited, lips pursed, and tried to stop his blinking.

The front edge of the lens began to unravel. It was a flimsy thing, nothing but a great spinning cup of solar sail bands, and it came apart with startling rapidity, its front edge rolling under it until it was tumbling forward and down, trailing long looping streamers which looked like the tangled tails of several broken kites, all falling together. A billion and a half kilograms of solar sail material, in fact, all unraveling as it fluttered down in its long trajectory, looking slow because it was so big, though probably the great mass of material was still moving at well above terminal velocity. A good portion of it would burn up before it hit the surface. Silica rain.

Peter turned and followed it in its descent, keeping well to the east of it. And so they could still see it below them, there in the violet morning sky, as the main mass of it heated to an incandescent glare and caught fire, like a great yellow comet with a hairy tangled silver tail, dropping down to the tawny planet. All fall down.

#8220;Good shot,#8221; Sax said.

Back in Wallace Crater they were welcomed as heroes. Peter deflected all congratulations: #8220;It was Sax#8217;s idea, the flight itself was no big deal, just another reconnaissance except for the firing, I don#8217;t know why we didn#8217;t think of it before.#8221;

#8220;They#8217;ll just drop another one into position,#8221; Ann said from the edge of the crowd, staring at Sax with a very curious expression.

#8220;But they#8217;re so vulnerable,#8221; Peter said.

#8220;Surface-to-space missiles,#8221; Sax said, feeling nervous. #8220;Can you invent #8212; can you inventory all orbiting objects?#8221;

#8220;We already have,#8221; Peter said. #8220;Some of them we don#8217;t have ID#8217;d, but most are obvious.#8221;

#8220;I#8217;d like to see the list.#8221;

#8220;I#8217;d like to talk to you,#8221; Ann told him darkly.

And the rest quickly left the room, wagging their eyebrows at each other like a bunch of Art Randolphs.

Sax sat down in a bamboo chair. It was a little room, without a window. It could have been one of the barrel vaults in Underbill, back in the beginning. The shape was right. The textures. Brick was such a stable staple. Ann pulled a chair over and sat across from him, leaning forward to stare in his face. She looked older. The vaunted Red leader, vaunted, gaunted, haunted. He smiled. #8220;Are you about due for a gerontological treatment?#8221; his mouth said, surprising them both.

Ann brushed the question off as an impertinence. #8220;Why did you want to bring down the lens?#8221; she said, her gaze boring into him.

#8220;I didn#8217;t like it.#8221;

#8220;I know that,#8221; she said. #8220;But why?#8221;

#8220;It wasn#8217;t necessary. Things are warming up fast enough. There#8217;s no reason to go faster. We don#8217;t even need much more heat. And it was releasing very large amounts of carbon dioxide. That will be hard to scrub. And it was very nicely stuck #8212; it#8217;s hard to get CO₂ out of carbonates. As long as one doesn#8217;t melt the rock, it stays.#8221; He shook his head. #8220;It was stupid. They were just doing it because they could. Canals. I don#8217;t believe in canals.#8221;

#8220;So it just wasn#8217;t the right kind of terraforming for you.#8221;

#8220;That#8217;s right.#8221; He met her stare calmly. #8220;I believe in the terra-forming outlined in Dorsa Brevia. You signed off too. As I recall.#8221;

She shook her head.

#8220;No? But the Reds signed?#8221;

She nodded.

#8220;Well#8230; it makes sense to me. I said this to you before. Human-viable to a certain elevation. Above that, air too thin and cold. Go slow. Ecopoesis. I don#8217;t like any of the big new heavy-industry methods. Maybe some nitrogen from Titan. But not any of the rest.#8221;

#8220;What about the oceans?#8221;

#8220;I don#8217;t know. See what happens without pumping?#8221;

#8220;What about the soletta?#8221;

#8220;I don#8217;t know. The extra insolation means less warming needed from industrial gassing. Or other methods. But #8212; we could have done without it. I thought the dawn mirrors were enough.#8221;

#8220;But it#8217;s not in your hands anymore.#8221;

#8220;No.#8221;.

They sat in silence for a while. Ann appeared to be thinking. Sax watched her weathered face, wondering when she had last had the treatment. Ursula recommended repeating it every forty years, at a minimum.

#8220;I was wrong,#8221; his mouth said. As she stared at him, he tried to follow the thought. It was a matter of shapes, geometries, mathematical elegance. Cascading recombinant chaos. Beauty is the creation of a strange attractor. #8220;We should have waited before we started. A few decades of study of the primal state. It would have told us how to proceed. I didn#8217;t think things would change so fast. My original idea was something more like ecopoesis.#8221;

She pursed her lips. #8220;But now it#8217;s too late.#8221;

#8220;Yes. I#8217;m sorry.#8221; He turned a palm up, inspected it. All the lines there were the same as always. #8220;You ought to get the treatment.#8221;

#8220;I#8217;m not taking the treatment anymore.#8221;

#8220;Oh, Ann. Don#8217;t say that. Does Peter know? We need you. I mean #8212; we need you.#8221;

She got up and left the room.

His next project was more complex. Although Peter was confident, the Vishniac people were dubious. Sax explained as best he could. Peter helped. Their objections turned to practicalities. Too large? Enlist more Bogdanovists. Impossible to stealth? Interrupt the surveillance network. Science is creation, he told them. This isn#8217;t science, Peter replied. It#8217;s engineering. Mikhail agreed, but liked that part of it. Ecotage, a branch of ecological engineering. But very difficult to arrange. Enlist the Swiss, Sax told them. Or at least let them know. They don#8217;t like surveillance anyway. Tell Praxis.

Things began to shape up. But it was a long time before he and Peter took off in a space plane again. This time they rocketed out of the stratosphere entirely, and then far above it. Twenty thousand kilometers above it, until they were closing on Deimos. And then making a rendezvous with it.

The gravity of the little moon was so slight that it was more a docking than a touchdown. Jackie Boone, who had helped on the project, mostly to be close to Peter (the shape was clear), guided the plane in. As they approached, Sax had an excellent view through the cockpit window. Deimos#8217;s black surface looked to be covered by a thick coat of dusty regolith #8212; all the craters were nearly buried in it, their rims soft round dimples in the blanket of dust. The little oblong moon was not regular, but was rather composed of several rounded facets. A triaxial ellipsoid, almost. An old robot lander sat near the middle of Voltaire Crater, its landing pads buried, its coppery articulated struts and boxes dimmed by a fine dark dust.

They had chosen their own landing site on one of the ridges between facets, where lighter bare rock protruded from the blanket of dust. The ridges were old spallation scars, marking where early impacts had knapped pieces of the moonlet away. Jackie brought them down gently toward a ridge to the west of Swift and Voltaire craters. Deimos was tidally fixed, as Phobos had been, which was convenient for their project. The sub-Mars point served as 0° for both longitude and latitude, a most sensible plan. Their touchdown ridge was near the equator, at 90° longitude. About a ten-kilometer walk from the sub-Mars point.

As they approached the ridge, the rim of Voltaire disappeared under the black curved horizon. Dust blew away from the ridge as the plane#8217;s rockets shot exhaust over it. There was only a few centimeters of dust covering the bedrock. Carbonaceous chondrite, five billion years old. They docked with a hard thump, bounced away, slowly drifted down again. He could feel the pull toward the floor of the plane, but it was very slight. Probably he didn#8217;t weigh more than a couple of kilograms, if that.

Other rockets began to land on the ridge to either side of them, kicking clouds of dust into the vacuum, where they drifted slowly down. All the planes bounced on impact, then came down gently through their dustclouds. Within half an hour there were eight planes lined up on the ridge, running along it to the tight horizons in both directions. Together they made a weird sight, the inter-metallic compounds of their rounded surfaces gleaming like chitin under the surgical glare of unfiltered sunlight, the clarity of the vacuum making all their edges overfocused. Dreamlike.

Each plane carried a component of the system. Robot drillers and tunnelers and stamps. Water-collection galleries, there to melt the veins of ice in Deimos. A processing plant to separate out heavy water, about one part in 6,000 of the ordinary water. Another plant to process deuterium from the heavy water. A small tokamak, to be powered by a deuterium-deuterium fusion reaction. Lastly guidance jets, though most of these were in planes that had landed on the other sides of the moon.

The Bogdanovist technicians who had come up with the equipment were doing most of the installation. Sax got suited up in one of the bulky pressure suits on board, and went out the lock and onto the surface, thinking to look and see if the plane carrying the guidance jet for the Swift-Voltaire region had landed.

The big heated boots were weighted, and he was glad of it; escape velocity was no more than twenty-five kilometers an hour, meaning that with a running start one could jump right off the moon. It was quite difficult to keep his balance. Millions of tiny motions carried one along. Every step kicked up a healthy cloud of black dust, which slowly fell to the ground. There were rocks scattered on top of the dust, usually in little pockets they had made on landing. Ejecta which had no doubt circled the moonlet many times after ejection, before dropping in again. He picked up one rock like a black baseball. Throw it at the right speed, turn around, wait for it to go around the world, catch it chest high. Out at first. A new sport.

The horizon was only a few hundred meters away, and it changed markedly with every step #8212; crater rims, spallation ridges, and boulders popping up over the dusty edge as he trudged toward it. People back on the ridge, between the planes, already stood at a different upright than he did, and were tilted away from him. Like the Little Prince. The clarity was starting. His footprints made a deep trail through the dust. The dustclouds hanging over the footprints got lower the farther back they were, until they settled, four or five steps back.

Peter came out of the lock and walked in his direction, and Jackie followed. Peter was the only man Sax had ever seen Jackie really attracted to, in that intense helpless manner of the orbiting object, the lovelorn, yearning for orbital decay. Peter was also the only man Sax had ever seen who did not respond to Jackie#8217;s amorous attentions in any way. The perversity of the heart. As in his attraction to Phyllis, a woman he had not liked. Or as in his desire for the approval of Ann, a woman who had not liked him. A woman with crazy views. But perhaps there was a rationality to it. If someone moons over you, you have to wonder at their judgment. Something like that.

Now Jackie trailed Peter like a dog, and though their faceplates were a copper color, Sax could tell just by her movements that she was talking to him, cajoling him somehow. Sax turned to the common band and came in on their conversation.

#8220; #8212; why they#8217;re named Swift and Voltaire,#8221; Jackie said.

#8220;Both of them predicted the existence of the Martian moons,#8221; Peter said, #8220;in books they wrote a century before the moons were seen. In Gulliver#8217;s Travels Swift even gives their distances from the planet and their orbit times, and he wasn#8217;t that far off.#8221;

#8220;You#8217;re kidding!#8221;

#8220;No.#8221;

#8220;How in the world did he do that?#8221;

#8220;I don#8217;t know. Blind luck, I guess.#8221;

Sax cleared his throat. #8220;Sequence.#8221;

#8220;What?#8221; they said.

#8220;Venus had no moon, Earth one, Jupiter four. Mars should have had two. Since they couldn#8217;t see them, they were probably small. And-close. Therefore fast.#8221;

Peter laughed. #8220;Swift must have been a smart man.#8221;

#8220;Or his source. But it was still blind luck. The sequence being a coincidence.#8221;

They stopped on another spallation ridge, from which they could see the rim of Swift Crater, as a nearly buried ridge on the next horizon. A small gray rocket plane stood on the black dust like a miracle. Above them Mars filled most of the sky, a vast orange world. Night was falling across the eastern crescent. Isidis was directly above them, and though he could not make out Burroughs, the plains to the north of it were patched with great white splotches. Glaciers meeting up to become ice lakes, and the beginnings of an ice sea. Oceanus Borealis. A corrugated layer of clouds lay pasted right against the land, reminding him suddenly of what Earth had looked like from the Ares. That was a cold front, coming down Syrtis Major. The pattern of white clouds was just what it would have been on Terra. Spiraling waves of condensation particles.

He left the ridge, walked back toward the planes. The tall stiff boots were the only things that kept him upright, and his ankles hurt. Like walking on the sea bottom, only with no resistances. Universe ocean. He reached down and dug in the dust; no bedrock for ten centimeters, then twenty; it could have been five or ten meters deep, or even more. The dustclouds he had kicked up dropped back to the surface in about fifteen seconds. The dust was so fine that in any kind of atmosphere they might have stayed in suspension indefinitely. But in the vacuum they fell like anything else. Ejecta. There simply wasn#8217;t much to pull them back. One might be able to kick dust into space. He crossed a low ridge and abruptly could see over the sloping plain of the next facet. It was so obvious that the moonlet was shaped like some paleolithic hand tool, with facets knapped off by ancient strikes. Triaxial ellipsoid. Curious that it had such a circular orbit, one of the most circular in all the solar system. Not what you would expect of a captured asteroid, nor of ejecta flung up from Mars in one of the big impacts. Leaving what? Very old capture. With other bodies in other orbits, to regularize it. Knapp, knapp. Spall. Spallation. Language was so beautiful. Rocks striking rocks, in the ocean of space. Knocking bits off and flying away. Until they all either fell into the planet or skittered off. All but two. Two out of billions. Moon bomb. Gun stand. Rotating just faster than Mars above, so that any point on the Martian surface had it in the sky for sixty hours at a time. Convenient. The known was more dangerous than the unknown. No matter what Michel said. Clomp, clomp, on the virgin rock, of a virgin moon, with a virgin mind. The Little Prince. The planes rising over the horizon looked absurd, like insects from a dream, chitinous, articulated, colorful, tiny in the starry black, on the dust-blanketed rock. He climbed back into the lock.

It was months later, and he was alone in Echus Chasma, when the robots on Deimos finished their construction, and the starter deuterium ignited the drive engine. One thousand tons of crushed rock were thrown out by the engine every second, at a speed of 200 kilometers per second. All flying out tangent to the orbit and in the orbit plane. In four months, when about a half percent of the moon#8217;s mass had been ejected, the engine would cut off. Deimos would then be 614,287 kilometers away from Mars, according to Sax#8217;s calculations, and on its way completely out of Mars#8217;s influence, to become a free asteroid again.

Now it flew in his night sky, an irregular gray potato, less luminous than Venus or Terra, except that there was a new comet blazing out of its side. Quite a sight. News all over both worlds. Scandalous! Controversial even in the resistance, where people argued pro and con. All that squabbling. Hiroko was going to get tired of it and light out for the territory, he could feel the shape of it. Yes, no, what, where. Who did it? Why?

Ann came on the wrist to ask the same questions, looking furious.

#8220;It was a perfect weapons platform,#8221; Sax said. #8220;If they made it into a military base, like they did Phobos. We would have been helpless under it.#8221;

#8220;So you did this on the off chance it might get turned into a military base?#8221;

#8220;If Arkady and his crew hadn#8217;t fixed Phobos on the off chance, we couldn#8217;t have dealt with it. We would have been killed. Anyway, the Swiss heard it was going to happen.#8221;

Ann was shaking her head, staring at him as if he were mad. A crazed saboteur. Rather a case of the pot calling the kettle black, in his opinion. Resolutely he met the look. When she cut the connection he shrugged and called the Bogdanovists. #8220;The Reds have a catalog of #8212; all the objects in orbit around Mars. Then we need surface-to-space delivery systems. Spencer will help. Equatorial silos. Inactive moholes. Do you understand?#8221;

They said they did. You didn#8217;t have to be a rocket scientist. And so if it ever came to it again, they would not be pounded from space.

Sometime later, he could not be sure how long, Peter appeared on the little screen of the boulder car Sax had borrowed from Desmond. #8220;Sax, I#8217;m in contact with some friends who work on the elevator, and with Deimos accelerating, the cable oscillations to dodge it have been thrown off in their timing. It looks like the next pass in its orbit might collide with the elevator, but my friends can#8217;t get the cable#8217;s navigation AI to respond to them. Apparently it#8217;s really hardened to outside input, to prevent sabotage you know, and the idea of Deimos changing speed is something they can#8217;t get it to accept. Do you have any suggestions?#8221;

#8220;Let it see for itself.#8221;

#8220;What?#8221;

#8220;Feed the data on Deimos into it. It must get that anyway. And it#8217;s programmed to avoid it. Direct its attention to the data. Explain what happened. Trust it.#8221;

#8220;Trust it?#8221;

#8220;Well, talk to it.#8221;

#8220;We#8217;re trying, Sax. But the antisabotage programming is real strong.#8221;

#8220;It#8217;s running the oscillations to avoid Deimos. As long as that#8217;s in its list of goals, you should be okay. Just give it the data.#8221;

#8220;Okay. We#8217;ll try.#8221;

It was night, and Sax went outside. Wandering in the darkness, under the immense cliff of the Great Escarpment, in the region just north of where Kasei Vallis broke through the wall. Sei meant star in Japanese, ka fire. Fire star. It was the same in Chinese, in which huo was the syllable the Japanese pronounced as ka, and hsing, sei. A Chinese word to start with, Huo Hsing: fire star, burning in the sky. They said Ka was what the little red men called it. We live on fire. Sax was distributing seeds in the ground, the hard little nuts pushed just under the surface of the sand flooring the chasm. Johnny Fireseed. There in the southern sky Deimos burned, slowly losing way through the stars, rolling westward at its own slow pace. Now pushed by the pinpoint comet burst on its eastern edge. The elevator rising over Tharsis was invisible, the new Clarke perhaps one of the dimmer stars in the southwest sky, it was impossible to say. He kicked a rock by accident, bent down and planted another seed. After the seeds were all out, there were starter packets of a new lichen to distribute. A chasmoendolithic strain, very hardy, very fast to propagate, very quick to pump out oxygen. Very high surface-to-volume ratio. Very dry.

A bip on the wrist. He switched the voice into his helmet intercom as he continued to take the little nuts out of his thigh pocket and shove them into the sand, careful to avoid damaging the roots of any of the sedges or other ground cover that dotted the ground like furry black rocks.

It was Peter, sounding excited. #8220;Sax, Deimos is coming up on them now, and the AI seems to have acknowledged that it#8217;s not in its usual spot in its orbit. It#8217;s been mulling it over, they say. The attitude jets all through their sector have started a bit early, so we#8217;re hopeful that the system is responding.#8221;

#8220;Can#8217;t you calculate the oscillation?#8221;

#8220;Yes, but the AI is proving recalcitrant. It#8217;s a stubborn bastard, the security programs are pretty watertight. We can just figure out enough from independent calculations to see that it#8217;s going to be a pretty close pass.#8221;

Sax straightened up and tapped out calculations of his own on his wristpad. Orbital period of Deimos had started at approximately 109,077 seconds. The drive engine had been on for some, he wasn#8217;t sure, say a million seconds, speeding the moonlet by a significant amount already, but also expanding the radius of its orbit#8230; He tapped away in the great silence. Usually when Dei-#8217; mos passed by the elevator cable, the cable was at the full extension of its oscillation in that sector, some fifty kilometers or more away, far enough away that the gravitational perturbation was so small it did not have to be factored into the adjustments of the cable jets. This time the acceleration and movement outward of Deimos would throw the timing off; the cable would be moving back in toward Deimos#8217;s orbital plane too soon. So it was a matter of slowing the Clarke oscillation, and adjusting for that all up and down the cable. Complicated stuff, and no wonder the AI was not able to display what it was doing in much detail. It was likely to be busy linking up to other AIs to gain the calculating capacity necessary to perform the operation. The shapes of the situation #8212; Mars, the cable, Clarke, Deimos #8212; were beautiful to contemplate.

#8220;Okay, here it comes at them,#8221; Peter said.

#8220;Are your friends at the elevation of the orbit?#8221; Sax asked, surprised.

#8220;They#8217;re a couple hundred kilometers below it, but their elevator car is on its way up. They#8217;ve linked me up to their cameras, and hey, here it comes #8230; Yes! Oh! Ka wow, Sax, it must have missed the cable by about three kilometers! It just flashed right by their camera!#8221;

#8220;A miss is as good as a mile.#8221;

#8220;What#8217;s that?#8221;

#8220;At least in a vacuum it is.#8221; But now it was more than just a passing rock. #8220;What about the tail of ejecta from the drive engine?#8221;

#8220;I#8217;ll ask#8230; They ended up crossing in front of Deimos, they say.#8221;

#8220;Good.#8221; Sax clicked off. Good foresight on the AI#8217;s part. A few more passes and Deimos would be above Clarke, and the cable would no longer have to dodge it. Meanwhile, as long as the navigational AI believed in the danger, as obviously it did now, they would be okay.

Sax was of two minds about this. Desmond had said he would be happy to see the cable come down again. But there were few who seemed to agree with him. Sax had decided against taking unilateral action on the matter, since he was not sure what he felt about that tie to Earth. Best to limit unilateral action to things he was sure about. And so he bent over and planted another seed.